I feel the option in the F1 menu should be selected so anyone joining for the first time has to physically enable being selected as a detective as there are so many new people that should learn how to play before being selected as such a position.
No, then people will think you can't get it and won't learn. Its like pushing a newborn bird out of a tree, its gotta learn how to fly.
As much as I like this idea. I also feel it's not fair to new players to be denied a role until someone tells them how to enable it. Bad detectives are frustrating but everyone has to start somewhere
being a detective is one of the most fun roles in the game. In my opinion it's better than traitor, but that's just my opinion. To remove that from new players takes away a large portion of the game. Could you imagine if we did this for any other role? What if we made it so you can't play traitor until you hit f1 (which the game doesn't tell you) and enable it? That would suck. I know i would just be like "fuck this" and decide to go play darkrp instead.
I appreciate the input, everyone. It's enjoyable to have discussions and learn other trains of though.