Answered KOS's on detectives

i have 2 very important questions here today!

1) why on earth is kosing a detective KOSable? like if someone kills a detective because they are "kosed" they either have an extra chromesome or are a traitor theirself, it shouldnt be kosable though to call a detective a traitor (this may require an answer from a lead)

2)if an inno kosing a detective is kosable, an inno kosing an inno randomly is slayable, and a traitor kosing a traitor is rdm , why is a detective kosing a detective fine? ive seen a detective kos a detective, then someone reads that kos and says on mic "okay kos _____" simply repeating the kos and then getting killed for "kosing a detective" which loops back to point 1, it shouldnt be kosable

 

1. Calling a KOS on a detective is a false KOS.
2. A false KOS is a traitorous act.
3. Traitorous acts do not apply to detectives .
4. Detectives cannot call a false KOS in the operational sense of the term.

 

This about covers it.

Note, concerning your deleted post where you asked about the ratings. If you make stupid “jokes”, I wouldn’t expect positive ratings. Way to be a gleaming example of our community here.

 

But doesn't false KOS still apply to detectives?

 

Correct me if I'm wrong, but you mean if a detective false-KOS's an inno, or calls out a traitor for no valid reason.

As far as punishments for RDM goes. Yep.

But as far as being a traitorous act, it does not. You can not kill a detective for a false-KOS. You can't even kill a detective on a false-KOS on yourself unless they also shoot at you as well giving a fair implication that they are trying to attack you.

 

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the bigger concern here is when a detective KOS's another detective, then an inno reads that KOS invoice-chat out-loud and gets killed for it. Sometimes, even by the detectives that called it. Why is that allowed?

 

If you repeat a KOS, you're responsible for it (in terms of gameplay), you may be killed for it- it's often difficult to keep track of KOS's and we don't expect every player to remember who originally called it. This is why I don't personally repeat KOS's.

 

No, I meant that, in the current rules, Detective A calls a KOS on Detective B, Player C then repeats that KOS in voice chat, and Detective A can then kill Player C for calling out a KOS on a detective, even though they were just repeating the KOS. My question, and I think Dazza's too, is why is that allowed.

Edit:
I'll make a suggestion in a moment, but I am amazed that a Detective can call a KOS on someone, then immediately kill other players for repeating that KOS, and that's not somehow considered loopholing.

https://www.seriousgmod.com/threads/loophole-closure-detectives-kosing-other-detectives.47958/

 

I know I'm going to get flak for pushing this topic, especially with the suggestion open, but I am having an immense amount of trouble understanding the logic in allowing the Detective to kill people for this and have it be condoned in the rules. Since I can only see this being used as loopholing, can somebody please explain a situation where this would be useful in standard gameplay, if one exists, for what little remains of my sanity?

 

Also thread locked because the main question has been answered.
If you have any other questions, you are free to make a new qna thread.